Introducing Via Transilvanica

Every now and then, people ask if I can recommend a long-distance hiking path. I don’t know why they would ask me, of all people, because I am really more of a couch potato myself.

But one thing I know: Eastern Europe is very much underrated. And Romania is particularly wonderful.

Via Transilvanica is a relatively new long-distance path, completed just a few years ago. It traverses all of Romania from north to south (and probably the other way, too), stretching over 1,400 km. I haven’t walked this route yet, but I will dare to pass on this recommendation, because I have had nothing but the best experience anywhere else in Romania.

In 70 daily stages, each covering around a manageable 20 km, the route passes through a wide variety of landscapes, without crossing steep mountains or any other challenging terrain. It is more suited for leisurely hikers who want to get to know the country and its people. For that reason, accommodation with locals is available in almost every village along the entire trail. So if you don’t want to, you don’t have to bivouac or camp a single night.

I found three videos that provide a good overview of this long-distance hiking trail, the different regions and landscapes, and the hospitality. But above all, they show that the Via Transilvanica was and is a project of thousands of volunteers who take care of the trails, maintain the signposts, publish hiking guides and accommodation directories, and involve the local community.

The following second part covers the regions where I was usually stumbling through the forests and across the gentle hills: Szeklerland and Transylvania. From minute 18:40, it enters Mureș County, where I lived in 2014 and 2015.

The hiking trail does not lead through the charming city of Târgu Mureș, but that’s the way it is with trails that mainly want to incorporate nature and village life. But as you will see, there is plenty of culture and impressive architecture even in the smallest villages. I don’t even know if there is another hiking trail that passes through that many UNESCO World Heritage Sites.

The third part delves deep into Romanian and Roman history. As you may have noticed from the language, there is a connection. (Last year, I had a Romanian Couchsurfing guest staying with me who made the bold claim that Latin was derived from Romanian rather than the other way around, and that the Vatican only exists to suppress this linguistic truth. Otherwise, a Romanian would become Pope and then Romania could finally get back the gold that was stolen by the Soviet Union. Which would make Romania the richest country in the world. Were it not for the Vatican! I gave him a second beer, so he would fall asleep soon. But he was a nice guy.)

In addition, this last episode once again highlights the hospitality, warmth and helpfulness that once led me to feel completely accepted, integrated and at home in Romania.

One thing has probably become evident from the videos: If you want to lose weight or give up alcohol, hiking through Romania won’t help. However, if your mind and soul are more important to you than cholesterol and liver levels, then Romania is the place for you!

Links:

Posted in Romania, Travel | Tagged | Leave a comment

How much does Child Custody cost?

A potential client is trying to convince me to take on her case, listing the reasons why she should have child custody.

“I have a house, I have a car, my ex doesn’t have anything,” she says, among other equally unconvincing reasons. “We even have a swimming pool.”

“Well, you are not going to have that house and that car for much longer,” I inform her.

She is visibly shocked: “Why not?”

“Because you will have to sell them to pay my fees.”


Maybe it’s my working-class background. Maybe it’s my disdain for most matters material and for showoffs. Or for non-sequitur arguments. In any case, I have a problem with parents who think they are entitled to child custody because they are wealthier than the other parent.

Luckily, they never hire me. Because in the end, their wealth is more important to them than their child.

By the way, I have neither a car, nor a house, and I am perfectly happy. But then, I don’t have any children either. – Which happens to be the best advice I can pass on. For free.

Posted in Family Law, Law | Tagged , , , , | 6 Comments

The End of Skype

As I reach those echelons of advanced age, where, just a few short centuries ago I would have been regarded as a wise man, I sometimes feel the impact of age discrimination already. For example when they randomly change well-functioning processes just to confuse people. Or when they fire people to make things “digital”, which just means that you can’t understand nothing no more, when in the good old times you simply walked down to the Post Office to ask. Or when they take away software that we had just gotten used to. Like Microsoft is now threatening to do to Skype.

The end of Skype will mean two things:

People like me, who are slow to adapt to ever-changing technological gadgets, are being shut out from electronic communication. Henceforth, no more fancy video chats for me. (Anyhow, I always found it strange that people from the southern hemisphere weren’t shown upside down.) Luckily, I still have a proper phone (the number is in the phone book) and an address, where you can send letters, postcards and books.

Second, I have been using Skype to communicate with my international clients for decades. This shows that even one’s own business, if it’s based on some computer tool, can be reduced to rubble at the whim of a madman.

Either way, I shall have more time to read books, to stroll across flower-strewn hills, and to be happily unavailable to the big wide world.

Posted in Technology | 19 Comments

FAQ on Reclaiming German Citizenship – updated 2025

The FAQ on German Citizenship are the most popular post on my blog. But some aspects are so complicated, they warrant their own list of FAQ, like those on reclaiming German citizenship or German citizenship by restitution.

I am a German lawyer, specializing in German citizenship law. These FAQ are supposed to give you an overview of the basic principles governing this area of law, so you can decide whether a paid consultation is worth it.

Before asking a new question, please read through the many comments which may already answer your question. And if you find these FAQ useful, or if you ask a new question, it would be very nice of you to support this blog. Thank you!

1. Why would someone lose German citizenship in the first place?

The main ways to lose German citizenship were applying for and receiving citizenship of another country without prior permission from Germany (§ 25 StAG until June 2024), voluntarily serving in the armed forces of another country (§ 28 StAG) and renunciation (§ 26 StAG).

But it becomes endlessly more complex because different laws were in place at different times. Until 1949 or 1953, depending on the specific circumstances, German women who married a foreign man automatically lost German citizenship. Until 1913, German citizenship could be lost by living abroad for more than 10 years and not registering with a German consulate. And then, between 1933 and 1945, the Nazis stripped many people of German citizenship as an act of punishment or out of anti-Semitic ideology.

2. I am a history geek. Tell me more about that Nazi policy.

Ok. After all, I am a history geek, too:

In November 1941, the Third Reich passed a law that deprived all Jewish Germans who were living abroad at the time (or moved abroad later) of their German citizenship.

In addition to that, since July 1933 there had been a law that allowed the individual revocation of German citizenship, which was mostly applied to opposition activists and intellectuals. If your ancestors were among the 39,006 victims of that policy, they were in the good company of people like Albert Einstein, Willy Brandt, Hannah Arendt, Thomas Mann, Heinrich Mann, Bertolt Brecht and others.

3. I am a descendant of someone in one of these two groups of people. Does this mean I can now apply for a German passport?

Generally yes.

Art. 116 II of the German Constitution states that all people who were deprived of their German citizenship on “political, racial or religious grounds” between 1933 and 1945 can reclaim Germany citizenship. What is of more interest to you is that Art. 116 II GG extends this to descendants.

Since 2021, there is a new § 15 StAG, widening the number of people who are eligible to reclaim German citizenship. So even if you were previously told (by me or by someone else) that you are not eligible, it may well be worth to look into your case again.

4. That sounds interesting. What are the changes?

First, the new § 15 no. 1 StAG extends the eligible group of people to all those who lost or gave up their German citizenship – for the reasons outlined in Art. 116 II GG – before 1955. Previously, the loss of German citizenship had to have occurred before 1945. The purpose of the new § 15 StAG in this respect is to cover German citizens who fled from the Nazis, but only lost their German citizenship after the end of the Nazi regime, for example through naturalization in another country after 1945.

Second, § 15 no. 2 StAG now explicitly covers people who were excluded from mass-naturalizations of ethnic Germans based on racial grounds. For example, when the Nazis occupied the city of Gdansk/Danzig, the population automatically became German. Jews were however excluded from this.

Third, § 15 no. 3 StAG now covers people who did apply or could have applied for German citizenship between 1933 and 1945, but did not receive German citizenship due to racial or political discrimination. This concerns Jews, but for example also communists.

Fourth, § 15 no. 4 StAG extends the possibility to obtain German citizenship to people who were deported or forced to emigrate from the German Reich by the Nazis. In this case, the applicants (or their parents, grand-parents, etc.) need not have been German citizens! It covers any of your ancestors, of whatever nationality, who lived in Nazi Germany and were forced to leave.

5. And if I qualify, this also extends to my children?

Yes. Even to grandchildren.

6. What about the non-Nazi related cases, for example when I lost German citizenship because I applied for US/Jamaican/Australian citizenship without prior permission from Germany, but now I want to move back to Germany?

First of all, you don’t need German citizenship in order to move to Germany (§ 38 II AufenthG).

§ 13 StAG allows for the discretionary re-naturalization of former German citizens (and their minor children). You need to present a compelling case, though. In my experience, only very few applicants make the cut, because you need to show that it would be in the national interest of Germany to re-naturalize you. Unless you are some great sportsperson or scientist, that’s not easy.

But luckily, in recent years the European Court of Justice has come to the rescue of many ex-Germans who want their citizenship back.

7. What does the European Union have to do with German citizenship law?

It’s a bit complicated and counterintuitive, because citizenship law is one of the bastions of national law within the European Union. But lawyers can be creative:

With each national citizenship of an EU member country, you automatically have/receive the citizenship of the European Union, pursuant to Art. 20 TFEU. If you have a passport from any EU country on hand, just look at it, and you will see that it is also a passport of the European Union. For a long time, this EU citizenship was pretty much disregarded, because you cannot obtain, keep or lose it independently. It is tied to the national citizenship of a member state.

But then came the European Court of Justice (ECJ, the highest court of the European Union, not to be confused with the European Court of Human Rights, which is not an EU court) in 2019 and ruled that the loss of EU citizenship in the context of losing the national citizenship of an EU member state (for example the loss of German citizenship when you got naturalized in another country before 2024) needs to pass a proportionality test under European law.

In several subsequent decisions, the ECJ required that the proportionality test takes into account the specific situation of the EU citizen at the time. And this gives you an opening if (a) at the time of your loss of German citizenship no proportionality test was carried out at all, or (b) if Germany at the time did not consider the effects on your EU citizenship.

Option (a) is less relevant for people who held German citizenship and lost it upon naturalization in another country, because they could have applied for a Beibehaltungsgenehmigung pursuant to § 25 II StAG a.F. If you didn’t and thus didn’t even give Germany a chance to make a decision about your citizenship, then that’s your fault. However, option (b) can be very relevant, because until a few years ago, Germany never considered the implications on your EU freedom of movement rights, should they withdraw your German citizenship. This is a huge opportunity for people who had been using their German citizenship to live in other EU countries, who have relatives in other EU countries, or other connections to other EU countries.

All of this has meanwhile been incorporated in the German Citizenship Act in § 30 I 4 StAG.

As you may have noticed, this is very complicated, so you shouldn’t try this yourself. For some of the other options, you don’t necessarily need a lawyer. Here, you need a real hot-shot citizenship lawyer.

8. I am the child of a German mother, but I was born before 1975 and therefore did not receive German citizenship. Isn’t that unfair?

Very unfair indeed. Finally, this has been recognized and there is a new § 5 StAG, which is supposed to bestow German citizenship on all those who previously missed out on it due to gender discrimination in older versions of the Citizenship Act. This concerns the following groups of people:

  • Children of at least one German parent, who did not receive German citizenship at birth (§ 5 I no. 1 StAG). The main cases here are children of German mothers born before 1975 and children of German fathers born out of wedlock before 1993.
  • Children of a German mother who had lost her German citizenship due to marrying a foreigner (§ 5 I no. 2 StAG). This is only relevant if your mother or grandmother married a non-German before April 1953.
  • Children who lost their German citizenship because their German mother married their non-German father (§ 5 I no. 3 StAG).

Like with the other restitution cases, this also applies to descendants of the aforementioned cases.

If you fall under any of these categories, you have the opportunity to obtain German citizenship by a simple declaration. But you need to make this declaration by August 2031, that’s the cut-off date.

9. Will I have to give up my existing citizenship?

No, you do not need to renounce your existing citizenship.

10. I lost German citizenship when I was a child because my family moved to another country and my parents filed for British/Brazilian/US citizenship for me. I was never asked. This is unfair!

We cannot undo everything that your parents did on your behalf when you were a child. Or do you want to return all these bicycles and Commodore computers?

But it is worth looking into the exact circumstances. I’ve had cases where only one of the parents signed the petition for a new citizenship although the parents had joint custody. In this case, German law treats you as if you never lost German citizenship in the first place and you can simply apply for a new passport without having to go through re-naturalization.

Posted in German Law, Germany, Law | Tagged , , | 225 Comments

Whither NATO?

When I photographed this mural in Kutaisi in Georgia (the real Georgia) in 2017, it seemed to symbolize the Georgian aspirations and hopes to join NATO. After all, somebody has to bring the wine for all the military exercises.

Nowadays, it makes you wonder if time is running out for NATO. And for Georgia.

Posted in Georgia, Military, Photography, Politics | Tagged , | 9 Comments

If Donald Trump had been President in 1941

“Winston, you have to stop with this warmongering, do you hear me? The Nazis just want your little island. And all of Europe. And to enslave millions. And to murder, rape and loot. And you come here, make a fuss about that inconvenience, and smoke your stinking cigars in my garden. How dare you??”

Posted in History, Military, Politics, Ukraine, USA, World War II | Tagged , | 16 Comments

Easily Confused (67) Peace Conference

Munich, 1938: A so-called peace conference at which the aggressor receives all the concessions he demands, the victim of the aggression is not represented, and the participants and observers act on the unbelievably naive assumption that world peace can be established that way. The dictator uses the reprieve for further rearmament, six months later annexes a democratic neighboring country, despite his promises not to do so, and less than a year later starts another world war.

Riyadh, 2025: The same.

Posted in Germany, History, Military, Politics, Russia, Ukraine, World War II | Tagged | 8 Comments

A realistic lawyer movie: “Maîtres”

Zur deutschen Fassung.

Most lawyer movies and legal series convey a completely skewed image of lawyers and courts.

But as most people unfortunately spend more time in front of the television than before an appellate court, these misconceptions inform their expectations. And then, people are disappointed when the whole law firm with five lawyers is not exclusively dedicated to their one single case, when the court still hasn’t made a ruling two days after a lawsuit has been filed, when the courtroom is neither packed with jurors nor with curious spectators, and when the judges aren’t constantly smashing their desks with wooden hammers. I can also regularly sense the disappointment of my clients when I don’t show up with a limousine and a chauffeur, like the “Lincoln Lawyer”, taking the tram instead. Or simply walking to court.

A particularly annoying example is “Suits”.

“Better call Saul”, on the other hand, I found surprisingly realistic.

Now, I don’t mean that the drug mafia kidnaps me, drags me out into the desert of New Mexico and tries to shoot me every week. But that’s probably because the guys from the Sinaloa cartel read that I am totally capable of getting lost in the desert and almost dying of dehydration by myself. There’s really no need for them to get their hands dirty.

Beyond the superficial theatrics, “Better call Saul” presents the hard life of a solo lawyer with all its ups and downs: the exhausting courtship of clients, but then too many show up at the same time. You have to take care of everything yourself because you have no staff. And if you don’t get around to answering e-mails for a few days, clients show up at home.

But now I have discovered a truly realistic lawyer movie: “Maîtres” is a documentary about three French female lawyers who run a law firm in Strasbourg, focusing on immigration law.

Not only because I also work in immigration law did I immediately recognize a lot: Of course, superficial things like the older editions of legal commentaries, which serve as a base for laptops and lamps, or the smoker’s balcony (although in my case with relaxing cigars instead of a quick Gauloise).

But most of all, I recognized the clients and their stories. There are clients who come with a thick folder, everything perfectly organized. And then there are those from whom you have to extract every piece of information, as if they were in Guantanamo. (There is a movie about that, too.) Clients who bring their children to interpret, half proud, half ashamed. Clients who think they have done everything right because they have always worked hard and never been on welfare, because they speak French and all their children go to school, but from the state’s point of view, it weighs more heavily that they provided a false identity 16 years ago. (Please don’t do anything like that. It only leads to endless complications.) Chaotic clients who would need a secretary to make their appointments, to deal with their mail and, above all, to pay their bills. Clients with dramatic life stories. Clients whose case only has a half-baked chance of success, but whom you really want to help because they are nice people. And even the conversation to prepare for the naturalization test rang a bell.

At first I thought: “Convincing acting, chapeau!” Until I realized that the lawyers are real. And so are the staff and clients. They simply set up a camera in the office and let it roll. Of course only with clients who agreed to it.

Maybe screenwriters and directors should take a lesson from this. Dare to be more realistic. As Egon Erwin Kisch wrote: “Nothing is more exciting than the truth.” Or, if you really want to make lawyer movies, at least ask some real lawyers before. There are enough of us who are willing to help.

By the way, I don’t really want to complain the way it sounded above. In all honesty, it’s a pretty cool job. You sit around, listen to people’s stories, think, write a few letters, read a lot, and in between, you smoke.

I realized how privileged I am as soon as I watched the next film, which was about work on a construction site. Now, that’s what you can legitimately call a stressful work environment.

What about your job? Are there any realistic movies/series/books about it?

Links:

Posted in Cinema, France, Immigration Law, Law | Tagged | 22 Comments

FAQ on International Child Abduction – updated 2025

I have noticed that I receive many e-mails with the same questions, so I have started to post the most frequent questions – and of course the answers to them – for everyone to read. For free, can you believe that?!

As this blog post might already answer many of your questions, I invite you to browse these FAQ before you contact me (or any other lawyer) about your case.

Before asking a new question, please read through the many comments which may already answer your questions. And if you find these FAQ useful or if you ask a new question, it would be nice if you support this blog. Thank you!


1. What is an international child abduction?

The removal of a minor child from one country to another country without the (other) parent’s consent constitutes an international child abduction. It usually happens when parents who are from different countries split up and one parent wants to go back to his/her home country and takes the child with him/her.

It also constitutes an international child abduction if the other parent allows you to take the child to another country (usually for a holiday) and you then decide not to return the child once the agreed stay is over.

The latter is called an illegal retention, and it is governed by exactly the same laws as a child abduction.

2. What is the remedy against international child abduction?

If both countries are member states of the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (see question no. 11), you can request the return of the abducted child within one year of the abduction or retention.

3. What do I need to prove for a successful return of my child?

You need to prove that

(1) you have at least shared custody of the child,

(2) you have been exercising that custody, e.g. by living in the same house with the child or by having regular visitation with the child,

(3) your child had established residence in your country by living there for at least a few months,

(4) the other parent either abducted the child to another country or overstayed an agreed visit to another country

(5) without your consent.

4. Should I get the police involved?

In a regular case, I would recommend against it. Involving the police, the FBI and other people with guns and helicopters usually only adds to the tensions between the parents, which is the last thing we need. Also, the police are not exactly experts on international family law, so they might do things which aren’t really in your interest (like taking the child to a foster home or issuing a no-contact order).

Law enforcement won’t bring your child back without a court order and if you know where your child is staying, there is nothing that you need law enforcement for. And even if the whereabouts of your child are unknown, I have sometimes been quicker at finding them than the police. Most abducting parents aren’t very creative.

5. How should I react once I find out that my (ex-)partner abducted our child to another country?

Find a lawyer in that specific country who has experience with child abductions. Reunite has a list of lawyers who deal with international child abductions. In Germany, you can of course contact me.

Your lawyer should file for the return of your child as soon as possible to prevent any impression that you are giving consent to the abduction by tolerating it. You should also avoid any other behavior that could be construed or interpreted as consent, e.g. helping the other parent to get settled in the other country, sending money or personal items, working out a visitation schedule for contacts with the child in the other country, discussing which school the child should attend in the other country, etc.

During all of this, please keep focused on the primary goal of getting your child back. Too many people get totally sidetracked by filing criminal complaints, initiating family law cases in their home country, and pestering politicians, the press and the Pope. This is a very stressful phase of your life, and you need to chose your battles carefully.

6. Once I file for the return of my child, how long will it take?

Germany has vowed that child abduction proceedings in its courts should not take longer than 6 weeks, and that timeline is usually met.

7. Will I need to submit evidence about who is the better parent?

No.

The child abduction proceeding under the Hague Convention is not a child custody proceeding. It does not matter who is the better parent or who spends more time with the child or anything like this. It is in essence only a dispute about jurisdiction, i.e. about which country’s courts get to decide about child custody, visitation, etc.

8. Are there any reasons why the court would deny the return of the child?

This refers to Art. 13 I (b) of the Hague Child Abduction Convention, which gives the court the option to deny the return in case of a “grave risk of physical or psychological harm”. As an exception to the Hague Convention, this clause has to be interpreted very narrowly.

Because a return under the Hague Convention does not mean a return of the child to the requesting parent, but only to the last country of habitual residence (see question no. 9), parent-related arguments are usually not relevant.

Currently, this clause mainly becomes relevant with requested returns to Ukraine. So far, the German courts have ruled differently in different cases. Some courts have denied the return of a child to a country engulfed in war. Other courts have made it dependent on the specific circumstances and the place where the child would be returned to. Especially within a large country like Ukraine, there is quite some difference between the situation in different parts of the country.

9. What happens after I secure the return of my child?

As the decision is not a custody decision, the abducting parent is free to return to your country with the child that he/she had abducted. You therefore do not necessarily win physical custody for your child.

Actual custody and/or visitation needs to be sorted out by a court in your country. Most abduction cases are actually followed by cases for child custody and visitation very swiftly after the return of the child. So far, I have only had one case when the abducting mother did not comply with the court order and refused to return the child to the USA. So, I took the court order, picked up the 1-year old baby at Frankfurt airport, and flew him to Boston.

That’s the kind of lawyer I am. (Although, not knowing anything about children myself, I was very thankful that two ladies sitting next to us knew what to do with such a little human being.)

10. How do I prevent a child abduction, if I fear that one is about to occur?

If a passport is needed for the child to travel (which is not the case between many European countries), then you could of course try to hold on to the passport.

If you have very specific reasons to believe that a child abduction is upcoming (e.g. you found one-way tickets that your spouse booked, or your spouse transferred all his/her money to another country and quit his/her job), you could also get a court order in your country that specifically does not allow any travel with the child, that requires the deposit of passports with the court or the police, or that alarms the border and airport authorities that the child should not be allowed to travel.

11. Which countries are member states of the Hague Convention?

A current list can be found here: www.hcch.net/index_en.php?act=conventions.status&cid=24 At the moment (January 2025), 103 countries are a party to the convention, although not all of them are always in full compliance. (With Russia being one of the worst offenders, as with anything that concerns international law.)

Posted in Family Law, German Law, Law | Tagged , , , , | 110 Comments

The Gnomes of Wrocław 

Wrocław is an interesting city.

The only thing that’s annoying are the gnomes. You’re sitting comfortably in the park or enjoying the view of the Oder river, and suddenly one of these little rascals emerges from the undergrowth and starts making a scene.

These creatures are everywhere. Even in the churches.

But some people like the dwarfs. Many tourists even come to Wrocław specifically, consciously and predominantly because of the hobgoblins and try to track down as many as possible of the more than 800 gnomes.

As you may know, I myself prefer concrete over metal. But for this taste, too, there is some beautiful art to be found in Wrocław.

Posted in Photography, Poland, Travel | Tagged | 15 Comments