How fucked up is US immigration policy?

Dear United States of America, you know your immigration policy is fucked up when some start-up entrepreneurs are so fed up with your strict visa requirements for people who wish to work, invest, start companies and create jobs, that they propose leasing a ship and mooring it outside of your territorial waters.

This is what is happening with Blueseed, a project to put a start-up office-park on a ship outside of American territorial waters off the Californian coast. They chose the location because of its proximity to Silicon Valley.

Blueseed-map-with-ship-buoys-and-distanceWhile I am generally very sympathetic towards schemes that circumvent immigration law, I am not convinced by this particular project.

  • Blueseed caters towards non-Americans who cannot obtain a work visa for the US, but wants to moor close to Silicon Valley to allow regular trips. Well, if you don’t get a work visa, you may get a tourist visa (still a big if, depending on your nationality), but then if you use that to go the US mainland for a visit, you are not allowed to do any work during that time.
  • One of the main problems with US immigration since 2001 is that even people who have a visa or who don’t need one because their country falls under the visa waiver program, still get denied entry once they reach a US airport or seaport. Sometimes it’s arbitrary, sometimes it’s because some terror suspect has a similar name to yours, sometimes it’s because the NSA found something suspicious in your e-mails or your Skype chats. – If you recognize that US immigration is a problem, why put up a ship close to Silicon Valley where you will again depend on US immigration for every visit ashore?
  • For those who only want to use the ship without visits to the US, there are much cheaper and better options. Many countries try to attract start-up businesses and are extremely helpful with immigration. Estonia, Chile or Bulgaria may not sound as cool as Silicon Valley, but you’ll have far lower expenses and you might even be treated as an entrepreneur, not as a potential terrorist.
  • If you insist on staying somewhere from where you can easily try to travel to California, why not set up shop in Mexico?
  • Blueseed states that it wishes to position the vessel outside of the territorial zone of 12 nautical miles, putting it in the “contiguous zone” according to the UN Convention of the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), but fails to mention (1) that the US has neither signed, nor ratified this UN Convention, and (2) that according to Art. 33 I a of UNCLOS, Part II, “the coastal state may exercise the control necessary to prevent infringement of its […] immigration […] laws”.

Overall, the only useful thing I see in this venture is that it points out how ludicrous and harmful US immigration policy is.

About Andreas Moser

Travelling the world and writing about it. I have degrees in law and philosophy, but I'd much rather be a writer, a spy or a hobo.
This entry was posted in Economics, Immigration Law, Law, Maps, Travel, USA and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to How fucked up is US immigration policy?

  1. dino bragoli says:

    “I’m all right Jack, pull the ladder up!” is an old English saying…
    I find it amazing that a country that was founded on immigration now has a locked door policy.
    I think it’s because populist politics wins votes, ask Berlusconi a walking talking living example.
    The war on drugs and the war on immigration is extremely popular, even more so than the ‘regime change’ type wars that cost lives like the Grenada invasion and similar, which btw I’m sure was inspired by the British ‘Falkands factor’ which proved very popular with Margaret Thatcher voters…

  2. I have oddly, never had a problem obtaining visas for potential employees (H1-B). I´d estimate in various companies about 300 or so visas, and I can only recall one that was rejected. Oddly, the only one I really didn´t want to process (but had to due to company politics) – Korean, IT degree (Master´s as I recall) to be employed as a glorified secretary was approved as well.

  3. crankypants says:

    Pretty much everything here is fucked up these days. a house divided against itself cannot stand. or something.

  4. Good evening Andrea,
    Maybe it is really not a bad idea to try to put up a company in one of your mentioned countries instead of the USA. Thanks for your advice. Bye Martina

  5. LostIn Time says:

    Filling the right way is an even bigger joke; I waited 26 years as the son grandson and brother of American citizens and I have just been told to start again application too old but this time provide two independent witnesses that were there at my birth over 40 years ago that remember my father being there, also want my school reports child support receipts for me etc etc etc if I do not provide everything requested file deleted again; cha cha ching keep immigrants paying another $1000 for doing nothing.

  6. US resident says:

    US immigration (specially employment based visa and green card), might looks like fucked up, but it is not. The reason is, the purpose of this immigration is to create a macro economy, businesses and to keep jobs and pay those people who are working at USCIS. With this sense I think the system is designed in this way purposefully. Yes, we are suffering as we are immigrants, born in different land which is not our fault, but for them it is big chunk of $$$. Its all about business on the name of principles or values or bla bla bla.. At every step of your visa process, artificially they created layers, processes such that you would pay $$ frequently, keep their staff busy and/or every time they can kick you out whenever they want. From our point of view, we loose so many things specially if you have family on working visa residing here with homes, and kids, and during green card or visa process, you will be told that go out of this country because of bla bla bla reasons. General american people here are very nice to new immigrants, it just government and its freaking artificially made rules that always give you feeling that you came from some planet X and you have to pay for coming US by frustration and $$$. At-least one good thing they can do is to give green cards to those who are already working in the country, supporting to economy and who has no criminal records. They still have opportunity to become stricter for outsiders, but why could not they give calm to those who are already living peacefully in the country.

Please leave your comments, questions, suggestions:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s