Shirin Ebadi’s Fear

The Iranian lawyer and Nobel Peace Prize laureate Shirin Ebadi has interpreted the harsh sentences imposed by the Iranian government on fellow lawyers in Iran as a “sign of fear” on behalf of the regime.

That may well be so, although I don’t think that Iran’s rulers have much to fear domestically after the protests of 2009 have fizzled out. And if this brutal regime will ever be brought down, it certainly won’t happen in courtrooms. The role of lawyers in dictatorships is limited to being tolerated in order to maintain an illusion of some resemblance of a legal system, while the judiciary is in fact just another tool of state power and oppression. (When I was interned at Evin prison in Tehran in summer of 2009 and charged with “conspiracy against the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran”, I didn’t get to see a lawyer for the whole week of my detention.)

Fear does play a role though. But possibly more so on Ms Ebadi’s part: When millions of Iranians took to the streets in summer of 2009 to protest against the rigged elections and for political reforms, Ms Ebadi preferred to remain in her exile in London. She, the only Iranian to ever win a Nobel Prize, did not consider it worthwhile to put her personal support behind the protests that were sweeping Iran at that time.

Would it have been dangerous for her to return to Iran? Possibly. But it was also dangerous for anyone else in Iran who took to the streets for protests. Millions had that courage. The Nobel laureate did not. But her presence would have led to even more international attention. Even for a brutal regime, there is a difference between shooting and killing student protesters and arresting hundreds on the one hand, and arresting or even harming the only Nobel laureate the country has ever had on the other hand. – Having seen thousands who took that risk without any of the protection that such fame and publicity bestow, and having taken that risk myself, I respectfully suggest that it would have been worthwhile for Ms Ebadi to step forward at that crucial time.

“Street protests? No thanks, I already have a Nobel Prize.”

But even in her chosen exile in London, Ms Ebadi has been painfully invisible: I have helped to organise a few events against the institutions of the Iranian government here in London, and I have participated in and attended many more. Ms Ebadi never showed up. – This a criticism that can be extended to many Iranians living in exile; but then most of these at least don’t pretend to be human rights activists.

Returning to the subject of fear, Ms Ebadi is quoted as saying: “Any person who pursues human rights in Iran must live with fear from birth to death, but I have learned to overcome my fear.” – It must be terribly fearsome to have to live in London and enjoy personal and political freedom, while in Iran thousands haven been imprisoned for political dissent and 47 prisoners were executed in the first 2 weeks of 2011 alone.

The Nobel Prize comes with an award of 10 million Swedish Krona.

About Andreas Moser

Travelling the world and writing about it. I have degrees in law and philosophy, but I'd much rather be a writer, a spy or a hobo.
This entry was posted in Human Rights, Iran, Law, Politics and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Shirin Ebadi’s Fear

  1. John Erickson says:

    While I can understand Ms. Ebadi’s fear for her safety and freedom, I have to agree with you that she should be in the forefront of human rights’ protests. While she may not have chosen to receive the Nobel Prize, she has nonetheless been recognized as a leader of human rights issues. In everyone’s life, there is a moment, grandiose or trivial, where we are selected by someone else to do something we do not wish to – the measure of a person is whether or not they step up. I realise that, as a famous and world-renowned person, Ms. Ebadi would receive”special attention” from the Iranian authorities, were she to be arrested. But she has been chosen, willingly or not, as a representative of the fight for freedom in Iran, and she should stand up.

  2. And as the esteemed lawyer and blogger Mehrtash Rastegar points out, Ms Ebadi is also quite arrogant:

  3. Mehrtash says:

    Thank you Mr. Moser.

    I have to admit, the main point of my article was not only her arrogance, but that she belittled the atrocious Iranian human rights record, as well as demonstrating a lack of knowledge on a key international women’s rights body to which Iran has undeservedly gained a seat on.

  4. Pingback: Why can Tunisians achieve what Iranians couldn’t in 2009? | Publish or Perish – Andreas Moser's Blog

  5. jim says:

    probabilty of arrest (for many many years) for ebadi: 100%
    probility of arrest of a normal demonstrators among thousands of others: < 0,1%

    that s why it was perhaps not a that coward decision to stay on abroad. ebadi's family in iran was massively intimidated… her sibling (or husband?) were arrested etc.

Please leave your comments, questions, suggestions:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s